Cover Letter Rubric
!
Pitch Room
English Career Communications · Written Assignment · Workbook Chapter 03

Cover Letter Rubric

___
OF 100
Name
Target role
Named reader
Organisation And Form SUBTOTAL ____ OF 10
Business letter format
Full marks: matches your resume header exactly. Weak: a missing date or address block.
012345
All essential parts
Full marks: four paragraphs, a full page. Weak: half a page reads as no effort.
012345
Paragraph One, The Hook SUBTOTAL ____ OF 20
Salutation and identity
Full marks: a named reader, then who you are. Weak: To Whom It May Concern.
012345
The position
Full marks: the role and your reason, in two lines. Weak: a paragraph before naming the job.
012345
How you heard
Full marks: the posting, referral or conversation. Weak: no origin given at all.
012345
Grabs attention
Full marks: opens on something only they would recognise. Weak: I am writing to apply.
012345
Paragraphs Two And Three, The Evidence SUBTOTAL ____ OF 25
Two body paragraphs
Full marks: one from your studies, one from your experience. Weak: one body paragraph only.
012345
Strongest qualification
Full marks: the first, with its number and method. Weak: a claim with no evidence.
012345
Second qualification
Full marks: different in kind from the first. Weak: the same story told twice.
012345
Relates to the job
Full marks: each ends by naming their own words. Weak: evidence left for the reader to connect.
012345
How they benefit
Full marks: names what the company gets. Weak: only about your own growth.
012345
Paragraph Four, The Ask SUBTOTAL ____ OF 15
Thanks the reader
Full marks: brief, sincere, and no apology. Weak: sorry for any inconvenience.
012345
Follow up with a date
Full marks: names the day, and who acts next. Weak: I hope to hear from you soon.
012345
Contact information
Full marks: phone and professional email. Weak: no way to reply without the resume.
012345
Mechanics SUBTOTAL ____ OF 15
Accurate grammar
Full marks: clean, and it survives being read aloud. Weak: errors that stop the reader.
012345
Professional vocabulary
Full marks: precise, with every hedge removed. Weak: I think, just, maybe, I know I do not have.
012345
Spelling and punctuation
Full marks: no errors, including both names. Weak: the reader’s name spelled wrong.
012345
Tone And Originality SUBTOTAL ____ OF 15
Originality and sincerity
Full marks: only you could have written it, for them. Weak: a template with the name dropped in.
012345
Professional assertiveness
Full marks: confident, and never asking for charity. Weak: ideal candidate, or grateful for any chance.
012345
Overall effectiveness
Full marks: a reader would want to meet you. Weak: nothing to remember.
012345
Final comments
Originality
Minus 15 points for content that was never asked for and does not belong in a cover letter. Read your own draft before you send it.
Matthew Clement · CAREERCOMMS.COMEnglish Career Communications